Ryan D. Miller and Paul Leonidas Lin Secure Complete Defense Verdict in $1.9 Million Excessive-Force Trial

Ryan D. Miller and Paul Leonidas Lin Secure Complete Defense Verdict in $1.9 Million Excessive-Force Trial

CMDA Law partners Ryan D. Miller and Paul Leonidas Lin obtained a complete defense verdict for the San Bernardino City Unified School District following a two-week excessive-force and civil rights trial. On November 10, 2026, a Riverside County jury returned a verdict for both the District and the former officer involved in the incident. The plaintiffs, who requested $1.9 million at closing, recovered nothing.

The lawsuit arose from a personal dispute over a lost cell phone. The plaintiffs alleged that an off-duty school district police officer drew a handgun and pistol-whipped one of them. They sought to hold the District liable both for the officer’s conduct and for alleged negligent hiring, supervision, and retention.

A central challenge for the defense was the former officer’s guilty pleas to felony battery and assault under color of authority in the related criminal proceeding. Plaintiffs’ counsel argued that those pleas constituted a binding admission that the officer had acted within the scope of his District employment.

Through a detailed examination of the evidence, the defense exposed inconsistencies in the plaintiffs’ claim that a firearm was used and established that the physical contact consisted of a single open-palm strike—the account the officer had provided from the scene onward.

The defense also challenged the damages claims without calling its own expert witnesses. Instead, the team elicited testimony from the plaintiffs’ treating physicians: one acknowledged that the injured plaintiff had exaggerated his symptoms, and each acknowledged a medical lien and a financial interest in the outcome.

Although the strike fractured the plaintiff’s cheekbone, the jury found that the former officer acted in lawful self-defense, that he was not acting within the scope of his employment, and that the District was not negligent. With the former officer representing himself, that self-defense justification was CMDA’s to develop and present, and the jury adopted it.

The result underscores the importance of disciplined trial preparation, effective cross-examination, and a clear presentation of the evidence in defending public entities against complex civil rights claims. As the prevailing party, the District is entitled to recover its costs of suit.

 


Ryan D. Miller is an equity partner and a conscientious and innovative litigator who focuses his practice on public entity defense, personal injury, labor and employment law, business disputes, medical malpractice, and premises liability. He is dedicated to obtaining the best results possible for his clients. His knowledge of the law and passion to fulfill the needs of his clients support his ability to achieve quality and successful outcomes. He may be reached at (951) 276-4420 or RMiller@cmdalaw.com.

Paul Leonidas Lin is a partner and a California State Bar Certified Criminal Law Specialist. He spent the first decade of his career honing and mastering the craft of the jury trial in the criminal courts, and has brought that experience to the civil arena to defend public entities such as school districts and the Judicial Council of California, where his trial instincts and command of the courtroom continue to produce results like this one. He may be reached at (951) 276-4420 or PLin@cmdalaw.com.

    CONTACT US

    I have read the Disclaimer

      CONTACT US

      I have read the Disclaimer